Customer feedback splits sharply. Repeat buyers praise well-packed, flavorful beef, while others report spoiled meat or cuts that were excessively tough. Several reviews mention orders that were canceled, shorted, or never shipped. Many say support did not respond, though a few describe timely deliveries and replacements. Overall, product quality and fulfillment results vary widely.
Examples from available reviews (Jul 2022 – Mar 2026).
Subscription orders are repeatedly canceled and products are unreliable.
“they cancel over half the order.”
Last box contained brown, smelly spoiled meat and caused food poisoning.
“brown, smelly, spoiled meat.”
Multiple orders, beef favorite and every cut was excellent quality.
“Every cut I have tried has been excellent quality.”
Christmas order never shipped and refund dispute ongoing.
“Ordered for Christmas never shipped.”
Reviews often mention canceled subscription orders, shorted boxes, and holiday or Christmas orders that never shipped. Fewer reports describe on-time delivery, including one case where a replacement was sent. These service problems frequently sit alongside refund disputes that remain unresolved.
Some customers say they spent large amounts and received low-quality cuts or too much gristle. Others describe multiple orders where every cut met expectations and felt like good value. Together, these opposing experiences leave buyers split on whether it’s worth the cost.
Many reviewers describe repeat purchases and loyalty built on earlier positive orders. Another group reports negative experiences tied to the company’s non-product offerings and money lost through an investment-related program. The two storylines are separate and strongly emotional.
Comments cluster into two outcomes: consistently well-frozen, flavorful steaks and cuts, or meat described as brown, grey, or black-spotted that some say was spoiled. Multiple reviewers report tough, chewy steaks and gristle that reduced enjoyment. At least one report connects eating the product to foodborne illness.
Several reviewers say they got no order confirmations, no replies to questions, or reached full voicemail boxes when trying to get help. Some complaints describe repeated contact attempts that went nowhere and included threats of litigation. A smaller number report reaching the company and getting issues resolved.
Reviews read as strongly polarized: high ratings focused on taste, packaging, and consistent cuts, and low ratings focused on fulfillment and safety concerns. Positive accounts highlight reliable quality and packing. Negative accounts center on unshipped or canceled orders, weak communication, and spoiled or unsafe meat.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Trustpilot (20) · Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: March 2026
Subscription orders are repeatedly canceled and products are unreliable.
“they cancel over half the order.”
Received $250 of beef that looked old and brown and got no responses.
“A lot of it looks old and brown.”
Ribeye steaks were so tough they could not be swallowed.
“I simply could not chew it enough to swallow it.”
Previously great steaks and service, now site shows investment issues.
“steaks were always great.”
Holiday delivery was slow for this order.
“Holiday delivery was slow”
Five recent orders delivered great quality and quick shipping.
“Great quality and quick shipping.”
Investments in the company's cattle scheme lost the reviewer thousands.
“fell for their "cattle raising investments" ponzi scheme”
Christmas order never shipped and refund dispute ongoing.
“Ordered for Christmas never shipped.”
Order not filled within promised 24 hours and no response.
“I have not gotten a response nor have my order been filled.”
Order unfulfilled and no response, voicemail full, and alleged legal action.
“The order has not been fulfilled.”
Order confirmation never received and multiple contact attempts failed.
“Never got an order confirmation.”
Reviewer prefers Agridime meat and received timely orders and replacement.
“prefer Agridime products.”
Filet mignons were the reviewer's favorite and considered great.
“they were my absolute favorite!”
Multiple orders, beef favorite and every cut was excellent quality.
“Every cut I have tried has been excellent quality.”
New York strip arrived well frozen, thick, and cooked deliciously.
“Package arrived in perfect frozen condition”
Several ground beef packages had grey/black spots and company refused date disclosure.
“6 of them had grey/black on them”
Bought $200 worth of meat that was horrible grizzle.
“Bought 200 worth of their horrible grizzle.”
Second shorted order and rude customer service, meat only okay.
“Second time I’ve been shorted by this company.”
Last box contained brown, smelly spoiled meat and caused food poisoning.
“brown, smelly, spoiled meat.”
Meat tasted fresh but was tough and lacked flavor compared to others.
“Agridine meat is tough.”
I recently had the chance to try Agridime meats, and I have to say that it was a truly delightful experience. The company offers premium quality beef that is directly sourced from their partner farmers in the USA. This ensures not only superior taste but also supports local farming communities across America.
The ordering process was easy and hassle-free on their website, with detailed information about each cut of meat available. They even offer huge savings compared to other high-end meat suppliers while still ensuring top-notch quality meat.
When my order arrived, it exceeded my expectations. The packaging was amazing and securely sealed, which kept the contents fresh for longer than standard supermarket packages would typically do. I can tell that there’s been an immense amount of thought put into every stage of this product's journey towards customers' plates.
As soon as we cooked our first steak, we were thrilled by how tender and juicy it tasted; we could barely believe it came straight from our American farms! It made me realize how different having farm-fresh beef is from using standard grocery products.
Overall, Agridime provides unbeatable value for anyone looking for top-quality meat without having to pay astronomical prices at big chain shops or go through tiresome processes of going directly to a farmer themselves; making fresh-from-the-farm meal experiences accessible for everyone!
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
Agridime is an online meat retailer selling beef cuts and other frozen products. It processes and packages meat and ships it directly to consumers. Customers order through the company website for home delivery. The company offers customer support for order questions and delivery problems.