This review highlights Abracadabra NYC's broad product range, helpful staff interactions, reasonable pricing and an organized store layout. For shoppers, that suggests a visit will likely be straightforward for browsing costumes, props or specialty items. If you plan to rent or need a specific item, contact the shop ahead to confirm availability. The analysis is based on a single detailed review, so consult additional recent reviews or call the store for up-to-date stock and rental policies before making plans.
Examples from available reviews (Feb 2026).
Visitor enjoyed a well-organized store with friendly staff and good selection.
“I recently visited Abracadabra NYC and was blown away by the selection of products available.”
Reviewer describes staff as friendly, knowledgeable and eager to help, answering questions and offering recommendations during the visit.
Reviewer reports prices were "very reasonable" compared with other New York stores, indicating perceived good value for purchased items.
Store is described as clean, organized and easy to browse; the layout and tidy presentation made exploring different sections comfortable.
Visitor highlights a wide selection of magic supplies, costumes, wigs, makeup, rentals and props available in-store.
Interaction with staff is characterized as helpful and responsive, with employees willing to answer questions and guide product choices.
The reviewer gives an overall positive visit, recommending the shop for unique gifts and party supplies based on their experience.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: February 2026
I recently visited Abracadabra NYC and was blown away by the selection of products available. As someone who has always been interested in magic, I found myself getting lost in the variety of magic tricks and props on display. The staff members were friendly and knowledgeable, eager to help with any questions or recommendations.
In addition to their impressive collection of magic supplies, Abracadabra NYC also boasts a huge inventory of costumes, makeup, wigs, rentals and props that are perfect for Halloween or any other dress-up occasion. Prices were very reasonable compared to other stores in New York City.
One thing that stood out during my visit was the cleanliness and organization of the store--everything had a place and nothing felt cluttered or overwhelming. It made browsing through all the different sections very enjoyable.
Overall, I had an excellent experience at Abracadabra NYC and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for unique gifts or party supplies. Their diverse range of products truly sets them apart from other shops in the area
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
Abracadabra NYC is a New York City retail shop specializing in costumes, theatrical supplies, magic props and related accessories. It is commonly visited by hobbyists, performers and customers seeking event or seasonal outfits. People searching for Abracadabra NYC often want product availability, rental options, or in-person shopping details.