Reviews Analyzed
16
We Collect & Analyze Reviews
Bullion Shark
Experiences & Reviews
Bullion Shark is an online seller focused on coins, bullion and related collectibles. Consumers researching this company typically look for information on pricing, shipping, returns and customer service when comparing coin dealers and online bullion retailers.
Overview & Key Metrics
Positive Sentiment
25%
Latest Review
93d
Overall Rating
1.9
Our Analysis
🎯
Service quality
Service-related comments are mostly negative: multiple reviews report orders that never shipped, delayed refunds, or missing items; one review shows a prompt correction.
Share of mentions
Weak
21%
💰
Value for money
A small number of reviews praise prices and perceived value; overall there is limited data on value, with few explicit price complaints.
Share of mentions
Mixed
7%
⚡
User experience
User experience comments are split: some buyers call the site great, while others report intrusive calls/texts and unwanted solicitations that worsened their experience.
Share of mentions
Mixed
7%
🔧
Product quality
Product quality feedback varies: some buyers received items in good condition, others report missing coins or suspected counterfeit pieces in multi-coin lots.
Share of mentions
Mixed
14%
📞
Communication
Communication is frequently criticized: several reviewers describe no replies to shipment or refund inquiries; one reviewer cites a timely email and label as a positive exception.
Share of mentions
Weak
18%
⭐
Overall experience
Overall impressions are divided: multiple positive accounts highlight price and product satisfaction, while a larger set report shipping, refund, or harassment issues.
Share of mentions
Mixed
32%
Our Independent Methodology
How we analyze customer reviews without bias
Data Collection
We analyze public reviews from verified platforms like Google, Trustpilot, and Facebook.
AI Analysis
Our AI detects patterns in genuine customer experiences without modifying content.
100% Independent
Zero company influence. No payments, no bias — just real customer voices.
Always Current
Updated regularly with the latest reviews and customer feedback.
Featured Customer Experiences
Representative examples from 16 verified reviews (November 2021 – October 2025).
TERRIBLE Customer Service
"Placed an order on July 10 at this company's Etsy "shop". Items never shipped. I asked the company to please provide a tracking number and/or shipping..."
Mike A
External Source
Jul 28, 2025
Featured for: Documented non-shipment and no response
PRICE & PRODUCT!! 100%
"The prices and the product that I received was well OVER what I expected. I just love collecting coins as a hobby but I also enjoy the fact that I fee..."
Princess Lee
External Source
Jan 16, 2025
Featured for: Positive on price and product
7 of 20 coins of the America's fake?
"I would have given a five star if it weren't for a few coins. Most looked real but some in the 20 coins of the America's..."
Felix Paz
External Source
Mar 08, 2025
Featured for: Reports multiple suspected counterfeit coins
Coins
"Absolutely love this site! Though I was initially sent the wrong bullion coin, an email was ready and waiting for me the next morning during their business hours after I contacted them. As soon as the situation was explained a shipping label was emailed to me & the correct item was sent out I believe by end of that same day. End result was exactly the item I wanted and a great experience with Bullion Shark customer support. I totally recommend it to anyone. That was a wonderful experience as a first-time buyer! Please nobody overlook this site...They never disappoint! Thank you :)"
Nicholas H.
Collected.reviews
Nov 02, 2021
Featured for: Positive service correction and resolution
All Reviews
Filtered, experience-based customer reviews from public sources; vague and duplicate submissions removed.
Filter by Rating
Filter by Source
Showing all 16 reviews
All Customer Reviews
Sources: Collected.reviews (8) · External Source (8) · Quotes shortened · As of: October 2025
M
Mike A
External Source
Jul 28, 2025
TERRIBLE Customer Service
Placed an order on July 10 at this company's Etsy "shop". Items never shipped. I asked the company to please provide a tracking number and/or shipping...
j
jack weddle
External Source
Jul 10, 2025
No Refund Until I Followed Up – Poor Service
Placed an order on June 10. Item never shipped. No communication received, despite the company claiming they email...
j
jerrymac
External Source
Apr 24, 2025
Bullion Shark Charlatans
The Bullion Shark charlatans live up to their name: sharks. Once they have your information, they use strong-arm, underhanded business practices to pe...
J
Jesse Dupont
External Source
Mar 22, 2025
I made a Order on the 3rd finally just…
I made a Order on the 3rd finally just got received it and was missing a coin an...
F
Felix Paz
External Source
Mar 08, 2025
7 of 20 coins of the America's fake?
I would have given a five star if it weren't for a few coins. Most looked real but some in the 20 coins of the America's...
L
Larre Riffe
External Source
Feb 23, 2025
Great Site! Great Prices!
Great Site Great Prices! Definit...
P
Princess Lee
External Source
Jan 16, 2025
PRICE & PRODUCT!! 100%
The prices and the product that I received was well OVER what I expected. I just love collecting coins as a hobby but I also enjoy the fact that I fee...
D
Dennis Badeau
External Source
Oct 11, 2023
I ordered 2 rolls of wheat penny coins
I ordered 2 rolls of wheat penny coins. The add said that i would receive random coin dates from 1909-1956. I received 1 roll of coins date...
�
🧡 Добрый вечер,На имя подтвердили билет на лото. Войдите на официальном сайте ->> https://forms.yandex.ru/cloud/62b7134577d8f2ba5124cbca/?hs=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d& 🧡
Collected.reviews
Jun 26, 2022
y9t4gi
21pt6h
�
🔥 На ваше имя прислали бесплатный лотерейный билет. Получить > https://forms.yandex.ru/cloud/62b34660f3756b5022fea213?hs=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d& 🔥
Collected.reviews
Jun 23, 2022
uxfku7
hcuo06
�
💙 Have you ever tried this sex game before? GIVE IT A TRY: https://dreamgirl22.page.link/H3Ed?hs=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d& 💙
Collected.reviews
Jun 08, 2022
9zjd79
84u02v
h
h=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d- <div style="display:none;">
Collected.reviews
Apr 28, 2022
l8r92cp
ptnyxin
�
💙 Nikki just viewed your profile! Click here: http://inx.lv/FXK6?h=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d- 💙
Collected.reviews
Apr 18, 2022
g6bb34v
uv41bp
�
❤️🔥 Doris is interested in your profile! More info: http://inx.lv/ww5J?h=b871e71bbb362a86f60501f0ac91ab4d- ❤️🔥
Collected.reviews
Mar 29, 2022
diqjh1zi
bgexhc
�
❤️ Jane is interested in your profile! Click Here: http://inx.lv/6wvQ?h=c521ef396d5a7ad14f3066774cd4da7b- ❤️
Collected.reviews
Feb 16, 2022
vvy8cce3
96t3mgp
N
Nicholas H.
Collected.reviews
Nov 02, 2021
Coins
Absolutely love this site! Though I was initially sent the wrong bullion coin, an email was ready and waiting for me the next morning during their business hours after I contacted them. As soon as the situation was explained a shipping label was emailed to me & the correct item was sent out I believe by end of that same day. End result was exactly the item I wanted and a great experience with Bullion Shark customer support. I totally recommend it to anyone. That was a wonderful experience as a first-time buyer! Please nobody overlook this site...They never disappoint! Thank you :)
Conclusion
Reviews of Bullion Shark show a mixed record. Several buyers praise price competitiveness and received products in good condition (for example, ID tp_6789292 and ID 240). However, multiple reviews raise serious service and communication concerns, including orders that never shipped, slow or absent refunds, and unresolved return requests (IDs tp_6887a1029f3b922ef0fc7d57, tp_6870271bc9f07e79bd8a3113, tp_6526b9f3a0f587e6aff59d0d). There are also isolated reports of missing items and suspected counterfeit coins in multi-coin purchases (ID tp_67cbd11a14e9603eca306e7f) and complaints about aggressive unsolicited contact (ID tp_680aaf6b4ef5fca892886d51). If you consider buying, check recent seller policies, confirm shipping and return terms, and consider starting with a small order to assess fulfillment and communication.