Reviews present a mixed picture for Cult of Coquette. Many customers highlight stylish designs, comfort, fast shipping, and helpful customer service in successful exchanges or replacements. At the same time, several reviewers report quality issues (separating soles, loose stitching, cheap trims), sizing that can run small, and a returns practice that often results in store credit rather than refunds. Prospective buyers should review the size guide, confirm the brand’s return and refund policy, and consider ordering early if buying for a specific event.
Examples from available reviews (Oct 2022 – Feb 2026).
Shoes comfortable and team expedited overnight shipping for an event.
“Cult of Coquette has amazing customer service.”
Shoes did not match website images and quality was appallingly low.
“the shoes looked nothing like the images on the website.”
Issue with heel tack was promptly resolved with replacement and gift card.
“They resolved the issue by sending out a replacement heel tap”
Two pairs fell apart after one wear and customer service was rude.
“After just ONE wear, the first pair completely fell apart”
Shipping and fulfillment are frequently praised for speed and packaging, but several reviewers report sizing problems, restrictive return rules, and mixed resolution experiences.
Some buyers say the shoes offer good quality for the price; others describe them as overpriced given reported craftsmanship issues and the store-credit return policy.
One reviewer noted a quick, straightforward checkout and good selection; there is too little data to generalize about the website or app experience.
Many reviewers praise comfort, style, and fit, while multiple others report craftsmanship failures (soles separating, loose stitching, cheap trims) and sizing inconsistencies.
Customer-service reports vary: several customers received timely, helpful support including replacements, while others describe unresponsive or hostile interactions and unresolved refund requests.
Overall impressions are split: many repeat buyers report satisfaction with comfort and style, while multiple reviewers report quality problems and difficult returns.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Trustpilot (30) · Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: February 2026
Repeated purchases with incredible quality and outstanding customer service.
“Their customer service was outstanding, responsive, kind, and incredibly helpful.”
After returning shoes for rash, company accused reviewer of 'friendly fraud'.
“They accused me of “friendly fraud” after I returned their shoes”
Shoes are cheap-looking, poorly made, and sizing is inaccurate.
“Shoes are HORRIBLE quality, poorly made and look SUPER cheap.”
Customer service quickly fixed ordering mistake and shipped both shoes.
“they quickly fixed things for me and BOTH shoes shipped out.”
Reviewer experienced uncomfortable shoes and alleged threatening, poor service.
“Uncomfortable HORRIBLE Customer Service!!!”
Gorgeous shoes arrived quickly and customer service efficiently handled an exchange.
“She was quick, communicative, kind and suuuuper efficient.”
Team tracked and expedited pre-order to arrive in time for a birthday.
“Cult of Coquette went above and beyond with customer service!”
Repeated returns due to inaccurate sizing and poor quality.
“Their size charts are totally inaccurate and misleading.”
Order arrived fast, matched advertisement, and shoes were comfortable.
“the shoes looked exactly like the advertisement”
Shoes arrived with toe marks and company offered inadequate compensation.
“Paid over $200 for shoes that arrived with toe marks!!”
Customer never received shoes and found support unresponsive.
“Never got my shoes.”
Shoes were uncomfortable and the store enforces a no-refund policy.
“very uncomfortable shoes and they have a NO refund policy”
Repeated purchases resulted in consistently wonderful experiences and stunning shoes.
“Everything from returns to questions/suggestions on sizing.”
Shoes run 1.5 sizes small and returns only allow store credit.
“Shoe size runs a full 1.5 sizes small”
Reviewer reports amazing customer service experience.
“Amazing customer service”
Top-tier customer service helped with an exchange to lower heels.
“Their customer service is top tier”
Customer faced unhelpful service, strict returns, and social media blocking.
“The most insanely unhelpful customer service and horrible company to deal with.”
Purchased many pairs and enjoys diverse styles for every occasion.
“There’s a style for everyone, and every occasion.”
Vegan shoes were stylish, comfortable, and suitable for long wear.
“These shoes are gorgeous and perfect for dressing up”
Shoes did not match website images and quality was appallingly low.
“the shoes looked nothing like the images on the website.”
Versatile, high-quality shoes praised as excellent value.
“These shoes are versatile and for the price point excellent quality.”
Consistent positive experiences with comfortable, true-to-size shoes.
“Mine fit true to size, and I am a 7-7.5.”
Two pairs fell apart after one wear and customer service was rude.
“After just ONE wear, the first pair completely fell apart”
Issue with heel tack was promptly resolved with replacement and gift card.
“They resolved the issue by sending out a replacement heel tap”
Order arrived quickly with clean, attractive packaging.
“I received my order quickly, and the packaging was very clean and beautiful.”
Shoes appeared cheaply made and craftsmanship and return policy disappointed.
“The quality was NOT worth $195.”
Shoes were overpriced, poor quality, and nonreturnable.
“Shoes are overpriced and bad quality.”
Stunning, comfortable shoes received quickly for a birthday purchase.
“The most stunning shoes!”
Two purchases delivered comfortable designer-style shoes with fast shipping.
“Super comfortable, fast shipping and the customer service was great.”
Shoes comfortable and team expedited overnight shipping for an event.
“Cult of Coquette has amazing customer service.”
I recently purchased a pair of heels and a handbag from Cult of Coquette and I have to say, I am very pleased with my experience. The website had a great selection of cruelty-free products that were not only stylish but also ethically made.
The checkout process was quick and easy, and my items arrived promptly in secure packaging. Upon opening the box, I was impressed by the quality of both products. The heels were comfortable to wear even for an extended period of time and the materials used felt durable and long-lasting. The handbag was equally impressive; it had plenty of room for all my essentials while still remaining lightweight.
One thing that stood out to me about Cult of Coquette is their commitment to sustainability. Not only are their products vegan, but they also use eco-friendly materials in their manufacturing process.
Overall, I highly recommend shopping at Cult of Coquette for anyone who wants stylish accessories without compromising ethics or quality.
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
Cult of Coquette is an independent direct-to-consumer women's footwear and accessories brand that sells styles such as heels and handbags through an online store. Consumers researching the brand typically look for product pages, size guides, shipping and returns policies, and customer-service contact options. When comparing options, shoppers often check material descriptions, photos, and explicit return or refund terms before purchase.