Skip to content

Lucy Nagle
Reviews & Experiences

Reviews are sharply split. Many shoppers praise fast delivery, careful packaging, easy size exchanges, and pieces they call luxurious. A sizeable group reports fabric issues such as pilling, holes, thinning, and shrinkage. Several customers also say customer service did not reply to repair or quality questions.

Overview & Key Metrics

Review count
16
Sources
trustpilot.com, Collected.reviews
Last updated
March 2026

What reviewers often mention

๐ŸŽฏ

Service quality

Service stories fall into two camps. Several reviewers mention quick replies, simple size exchanges, and fast order handling. Another equally visible group says emails went unanswered and repair or return requests were not resolved.

๐Ÿ’ฐ

Value for money

Value perceptions split between luxury and durability concerns. Some customers describe the garments as luxurious and long-lasting. Others say items started to pill, thin, or develop holes soon after wearing, which lowered the value for them.

โšก

User experience

Ordering and after-purchase experiences get mixed feedback. Some buyers point to quick delivery and smooth exchanges. A small set mention sizing issues, a broken zip, and one case of shrinkage after machine washing.

๐Ÿ”ง

Product quality

Quality feedback centers on fabric behavior and how items are made. Multiple reviewers report pilling, bobbling, holes, thinning, and pieces that stretch out or lose shape. Several others describe luxurious cashmere and say items washed well.

๐Ÿ“ž

Communication

Communication outcomes differ sharply. Several customers report fast, responsive help through the brandโ€™s channels. Multiple others say messages and repair requests were ignored or met with dismissive advice to wash the item.

โญ

Overall experience

Overall reactions are polarized, ranging from very happy to very unhappy. Positive comments focus on packaging, delivery speed, and a luxury feel. Negative comments focus on durability issues and poor follow-up communication.

All Reviews

For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.

All Reviews

Sources: Trustpilot (15) ยท Collected.reviews (1) ยท Quotes shortened ยท As of: March 2026

Martina Avery communication

Cardigan ripped while trying on and customer service did not respond to repair requests.

“Contacted them about repairing it through 6 emails and Instagram messages, no reply.”

Feb 15, 2026 ยท trustpilot.com
Grace Madigan quality

The jumper's sizing was incorrect and quality disappointed, so they returned it.

“Quality is not good; sizing is way off.”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Helen McEnroe service

Needed a size change and the process was straightforward and quick.

“Needed to change size and it was straightforward and quick.”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Annie O Hara quality

Scarf bobbled and stretched; advice to shave cashmere disappointed reviewer.

“Very disappointed, my scarf looks like a rag!”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Nic communication

Customer service is fast and responsive and quality cashmere is loved.

“customer service is fast annd responsive”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
customer quality

Admires luxurious cashmere sweaters and received brilliant service.

“Beautiful luxurious cashmere sweaters.”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Martina Keane quality

Several items washed well and remain classy and wearable.

“They have washed really well, they are classy and beautiful to wear.”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Liz Connaughton service

Items were beautifully packaged and arrived a day early.

“Beautifully packaged arrived a day early .”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Eileen O Sullivan quality

Cashmere sweater was thin and poor quality and lacked response.

“itโ€™s so thin and really poor quality”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
michelle burke experience

Received excellent service and loves the new wrap.

“Super service & amazing products”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
TL communication

Garments developed holes after one wash and customer service unresponsive.

“Worst customer service I have ever dealt with”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Aileen quality

Wool jumpers balled after first wear and loungewear zip broke.

“The woolen jumpers both started to ball after the first wear!!”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Anna Foxe quality

Leggings were thin, unsupportive, and started piling; no response.

“They are SO thin, not supportive at all”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Michele Stokes communication

Holes developed and customer service gave incorrect washing advice and blamed customer.

“i was just told how to wash it as if i didn't know!”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Customer usability

Machine-washable cashmere shrank significantly despite following instructions.

“both sweaters shrank in the 30 degree machine wash delicates/hand wash cycle.”

Oct 01, 2025 ยท trustpilot.com
Joelah Rose 4/5

I've been shopping for jeans for a while now, and this has been by far the finest experience I've had.

The product is fantastic, the shipping was lightning fast, and the customer support has been outstanding throughout the process.

My only purpose in writing was to inform you that I obtained my piping lounge pants in Derby.

It's simply stunning, and I'm overjoyed with how it turned out.

Also, thank you for the Moleskine notebook that you gave me as a gift.

Once again, thank you for your outstanding customer service.

You will be my first and only stop for future purchases.

Anyone who is seeking new pants should check out this store, in my opinion.

Dec 14, 2021 ยท Collected.reviews

Share Your Experience

Help other customers by sharing your experience with Lucy Nagle. Your review will be collected and included in our ongoing analysis.

Click to rate

Sources and methodology

This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.

About Lucy Nagle

Lucy Nagle is a fashion brand that focuses on knitwear and apparel. It designs garments and sells them through its website and retail partners. Product pages usually list materials and give sizing guidance. Online orders ship domestically and internationally, and customer support is available by email and on social channels.