In The Money Stocks
Experiences & Reviews
In The Money Stocks is a subscription-based stock and ETF trading service that offers trade alerts, educational content, and live trading rooms. Publicly associated with trader Gareth Soloway, the service advertises real-time signals, portfolio updates, and video analysis for active traders. Consumers researching reviews should verify documented performance metrics, subscription terms, refund policies, and how open positions and overall portfolio P&L are reported.
Overview & Key Metrics
Our Analysis
Service quality
Most reviewers report poor or inconsistent trade signals and execution; a minority say early signals produced profits.
Value for money
Numerous reviewers report subscription losses and question value; a few long-term users describe earlier profitable trades.
User experience
Some users note automatic closures and quick gains; many describe stressful experiences including margin calls and liquidations.
Product quality
Multiple reviewers criticise the trading methodology, prolonged losing positions and weak risk management; a small group reports profitable signals.
Communication
Several reviewers allege opaque reporting, removed negative reviews and hidden open-position reporting; one reviewer praises team transparency.
Overall experience
Most detailed reviews describe sustained losses and transparency concerns; a minority of reviewers report profitable results earlier.
Our Independent Methodology
How we analyze customer reviews without bias
Data Collection
We analyze public reviews from verified platforms like Google, Trustpilot, and Facebook.
AI Analysis
Our AI detects patterns in genuine customer experiences without modifying content.
100% Independent
Zero company influence. No payments, no bias — just real customer voices.
Always Current
Updated regularly with the latest reviews and customer feedback.
Featured Customer Experiences
Representative examples from 29 verified reviews (December 2021 – October 2025).
Stocks Trading
"I have been a member at In The Money Stocks for over a year now. I have received several signals which have resulted in quick profits. On average, the trades have turned over three to four times a day for about an average of ten days or more per trade. Most of the time my positions are closed automatically with most gaining anywhere from two to five points, resulting in roughly two hundred percent profit on each position. A couple of the trades resulted in over twenty points per share.
I have made several thousand dollars on these trades. I would truly recommend this service to anyone interested in trading Stocks with a potential for large percentage gains.
"
Integrity, Authenticity, Think for Yourself
"At a critical juncture in history, retail investors require transparency, understanding of the underlying dynamics, and the full picture to make infor..."
Prepare to hold onto losses for years
"Have been a subscriber for the service for ~3 years. It started well, the first year was even profitable (worse than index investing though) but the r..."
Margin calls, bad trades and hiding track record
"Been a member for over a year and completely agree with rest of the 1 star reviews, My portfolio got margin call 2 times. Many bad trades were held on..."
All Reviews
Filtered, experience-based customer reviews from public sources; vague and duplicate submissions removed.
Filter by Rating
Filter by Source
All Customer Reviews
Sources: Trustpilot (20) · Collected.reviews (9) · Quotes shortened · As of: October 2025
Integrity, Authenticity, Think for Yourself
At a critical juncture in history, retail investors require transparency, understanding of the underlying dynamics, and the full picture to make infor...
Do not do it
Do not do it. The idea that you can sho...
This machine is spam
This machine is spam. Avoid them. I did not received any payout from them. I have used other comp...
AVOID them Huge loss for 1 year member…
AVOID them Huge loss for 1 year membership with them. I was 1 year with them in day trading room and end up with loosing half of my entire saving that...
Scums bags they told me it no risk and…
Scums bags they told me it no risk and took me. The only opportunity...
This service is completely misleading…
This service is completely misleading and dishonest. Here is a simple analysis, you will see 80%-90% "win rate" which is a pointless metric without kn...
Prepare to hold onto losses for years
Have been a subscriber for the service for ~3 years. It started well, the first year was even profitable (worse than index investing though) but the r...
The service is a scam
The service is a scam. They don't show all of their losses. No transparency. They don't show a live/ active portfolio of the positions they are in and...
Margin calls, bad trades and hiding track record
Been a member for over a year and completely agree with rest of the 1 star reviews, My portfolio got margin call 2 times. Many bad trades were held on...
Believe the bad reviews
I've been with Inthemoney/VI for over 2 years. Gareth talks a good game, but the proof of his actual knowledge is in the trades. The first 6 months we...
Huge Losses Unable to Recommend
Steer clear. Down almost 40% in the last year. The first year of the service had decent performance but the last year has been atrocious. The problem...
My portfolio lost 20% with him. Not a master trader, just a master salesman
I was with the service for almost 3 years. Some of their methods can work decently when the market has volatility. However, most of the time, the mark...
Really really poor signal service.
Really really poo...
They shorted NVDA at $300 and kept…
They shorted NVDA at $300 and kept adding, need I say more?...
Misleading, stay away.
This trading platform is very misleading. Losing positions are almost never closed. The trader does no...
I am writing a new post since Gareth's…
I am writing a new post since Gareth's team is working hard to remove all negative reviews and like others my old post got removed too. I like Gareth,...
Long time customer advice - never sign in please
I have been a customer for several months. My simple advice is to never sign into this. What you see in youtube sounds all good but they never tell yo...
I wrote a review 6 months ago
I wrote a review 6 months ago. Which inthemoneystocks and Gareth Soloway has now flagged. They try to combat all the bad reviews and trustpilot even l...
Worstexperience
Worst long term experience. I followed him for over a year, had a decent return, but then some truths came to light. He adds to losers a ton and never...
STAY AWAY FROM GARETH SOLOWAY
STAY AWAY FROM GARETH SOLOWAY. HE IS A FULL BLOWN SCAMMER Gareth has a very tainted past. His new website is designed to lure newbie traders in, to tr...
Conclusion
Review content for In The Money Stocks shows a clear split: a few users report significant profits from signals, while many detailed reviews report large losses, extended losing positions, and concerns about risk management. Multiple reviewers specifically cite lack of transparent overall portfolio P&L, hidden open losses, and removal of negative feedback as recurring issues. If you consider this service, request clear historical performance that includes open and closed positions, confirm refund and cancellation terms, and consider paper trading or a short trial before committing capital. For larger investments, consult an independent, regulated financial adviser and compare passive index alternatives versus active signal services.