Many reviewers describe heavy trading losses, missed stops, and weak risk controls. They often mention hidden long-running losing positions and payout problems. A small number say the signals were profitable and the market updates were timely. Overall, feedback is sharply split between many negative accounts and a few positive ones.
Examples from available reviews (Dec 2021 – Mar 2026).
Reviewer claims Trustpilot removed their negative review and they lost over $550k.
“I lost more than 550k usd currently with this guy!!”
Member faced margin calls and large losses due to ignored stops and poor risk management.
“My portfolio got margin call 2 times.”
Reviewer claims negative reviews removed and losing trades hidden, warning to be careful.
“they have a lot of losing trades that they never close”
Signals produced regular profitable trades yielding substantial returns.
“I have made several thousand dollars on these trades.”
Complaints center on weak signals and results that didn’t match expectations. Several reviewers say they received no payout or call the signal service “really poor.” A few describe taking legal action to try to recover funds.
Most comments describe negative returns and sizable out-of-pocket losses tied to membership. One reviewer says they made several thousand dollars on trades, but mentions of good value are rare. Critics say the membership cost more than it delivered.
Some longtime customers report major drawdowns and warn others not to join. Reports include one-year membership losses and individual claims of six-figure declines. A smaller group says the market updates were useful.
Reviews about quality point to broken risk management and poor trade picks. Several say stop-losses were ignored, they were pushed to short into rallies, and positions were held as losses piled up. Reviewers also mention not having a clear, consolidated view of portfolio P&L.
Many describe communication as unclear, with repeated claims that losing trades get hidden and negative reviews removed. Some allege win-rate numbers are shown selectively while long-term losses are left out. One review praises the team for market information and transparency.
Reviews are split between many low ratings and a few positive testimonials. The main themes are financial loss, unclear reporting, and weak risk controls. A small number of users report profitable trades and helpful updates.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Trustpilot (22) · Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: March 2026
Reviewer warns service adds to losing trades and lacks risk management.
“No risk to reward ratio. No risk management.”
Team provided transparency and market information for informed decisions.
“Gareth and the team provide this information.”
Reviewer warns shorting alone is dangerous and causes losses.
“The idea that you can short alone is dangerous and you will lose.”
Reviewer did not receive any payout and advises avoiding the company.
“I did not received any payout from them.”
One-year membership resulted in large losses and poor day-trading practices.
“AVOID them Huge loss for 1 year membership with them.”
Reviewer claims they were misled about no-risk and only recovered money via lawyer.
“Scums bags they told me it no risk and...”
Service misleads with win-rate metrics and hides long-term losses.
“hiding the massive losses which Gareth holds for multiple years”
Subscriber reports long-term massive losses and lack of overall portfolio transparency.
“Service subscribers are never shown total portfolio P&L”
Reviewer alleges no transparency and substantial losses from fund and service.
“The service is a scam.”
Member faced margin calls and large losses due to ignored stops and poor risk management.
“My portfolio got margin call 2 times.”
Long-term subscriber reports severe losses and hidden losing trades.
“Take it from experience, DO NOT do it.”
Reviewer lost almost 40% last year and criticizes accumulating bad trades.
“Down almost 40% in the last year.”
Service encouraged shorts in strong stocks leading to significant portfolio losses.
“They will tell you to stay in these massive losing positions for years”
Reviewer says the signal service is really poor.
“Really really poor signal service.”
Reviewer claims traders shorted NVDA and rely on subscription revenue, not trading profits.
“They shorted NVDA at $300 and kept adding, need I say more?”
Reviewer says losing positions are rarely closed and trader ignores stops.
“Losing positions are almost never closed.”
Reviewer claims negative reviews removed and losing trades hidden, warning to be careful.
“they have a lot of losing trades that they never close”
Longtime customer lost over $150k and warns others not to sign up.
“I a lost more than 150k USD and trying to recover now as much as I can.”
Reviewer claims Trustpilot removed their negative review and they lost over $550k.
“I lost more than 550k usd currently with this guy!!”
Follower says poor long-term results, added to losers and lost significant money.
“Worst long term experience.”
Reviewer calls Gareth Soloway a scammer and warns others to avoid him.
“STAY AWAY FROM GARETH SOLOWAY”
I have been a member at In The Money Stocks for over a year now. I have received several signals which have resulted in quick profits. On average, the trades have turned over three to four times a day for about an average of ten days or more per trade. Most of the time my positions are closed automatically with most gaining anywhere from two to five points, resulting in roughly two hundred percent profit on each position. A couple of the trades resulted in over twenty points per share.
I have made several thousand dollars on these trades. I would truly recommend this service to anyone interested in trading Stocks with a potential for large percentage gains.
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
In The Money Stocks offers stock market commentary and trading signals for retail traders. It sends trade alerts and market analysis through subscription membership tiers. The service shares content via email alerts, its website, and social media. Coverage usually focuses on equities and active trading approaches, including real-time alerts subscribers can act on.