Reviews provided show consistent strengths in fast shipping, clear tracking updates and competitive pricing, with many customers reporting items arrived new and well packaged. Several reviewers are repeat buyers and explicitly praise customer support and promotional pricing. However, a minority of reviews describe delivery failures, unresolved disputes and product-description mismatches (for example band type or gemstone appearance). If you consider purchasing, verify item details and tracking, save order/shipping records, and review return/complaint procedures before buying higher-value items.
Examples from available reviews (Nov 2021 – Feb 2026).
Item was never delivered and company blamed USPS despite complaint.
“My item was never delivered”
They consistently offer the best prices and great customer service.
“MGS pretty much always has the best price for what I'm looking for.”
Watch arrived in perfect, like-new condition with timely shipping.
“received on time in perfect condition”
Item description misrepresented the band material; watch otherwise nice.
“The listing says Velcro band, BUT I got a rubber/silicon band.”
Several shoppers describe knowledgeable, helpful staff and extra effort from representatives; a smaller set report unresolved issues around deliveries and returns.
Many reviewers report competitive pricing, frequent discounts and good deals on watches, and consider purchases to offer strong value for the cost.
Site navigation, checkout and delivery are repeatedly described as easy and fast; customers frequently note quick shipping and straightforward ordering.
Most buyers say items arrive new, well packaged and as described; a minority report mismatches such as incorrect bands or gem descriptions.
Many reviews mention timely tracking updates and responsive contact; a few cite poor responses when chasing missing deliveries.
Overall feedback is largely positive with repeat purchases and recommendations, though some customers report delivery or product-description problems.
For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.
Sources: Trustpilot (40) · bbb.org (3) · Collected.reviews (1) · Quotes shortened · As of: February 2026
Watch was a good price and delivered promptly.
“Great watch at a good price.”
Store offered great prices and fast shipping with tracking.
“Great prices, fast shipping with tracking”
Fast shipping, good price, and a great product.
“fast shipping, great price, and great product”
Both product and service were outstanding and recommended.
“Outstanding product; outstanding service.”
Ordering and checkout were easy and the order shipped promptly.
“The browsing and ordering process on the web site were very easy.”
Item arrived in perfect new condition and offered great value.
“Perfect new condition and great value!”
Item matched expectations and was packaged perfectly.
“It was exactly what I was hoping for, it was packaged perfectly.”
Order was received in great condition and delivered timely.
“I received my order in a great and timely manner.”
Item was brand new with correct papers and delivered quickly.
“brand new in the box with the correct papers.”
Despite reviews, delivery was very fast and the product was great.
“very fast delivery and a great product”
Good pricing and overall positive experience; would purchase again.
“Good pricing on this watch, I was too indecisive on Black Friday or could have done even better!”
Watch arrived quickly in original packaging and appeared brand new.
“I received the watch quickly and in the original manufacturer packing.”
Company offered great prices and a positive experience.
“Great company and great price!”
Product looks better in person and customer service was great.
“Looks better in person great customer service!”
Item arrived quickly and reviewer is excited to gift it.
“Arrived quickly can’t wait to open it for Christmas for my husband ;)”
Checkout was easy and tracking was available for shipment.
“easy check out track available on shipping !!”
Product was great, shipping fast, and reviewer very satisfied.
“Great product! Fast shipping! Very Satisfied.”
Watch arrived well packaged and promptly.
“Watch arrived well packaged and in a prompt manner.”
Product was genuine, high quality, and offered good value.
“Genuine Product. Amazing quality. Good value”
Delivery went perfectly and reviewer is satisfied with the item.
“Delivery was perfect no problems involved i am satisfied with my item”
Website was easy to use and product arrived quickly.
“Easy to negotiate website.”
They consistently offer the best prices and great customer service.
“MGS pretty much always has the best price for what I'm looking for.”
Order arrived on time and offered good value.
“Delivered on time and the quality of the products I ordered is just what I expected;”
Watch was delivered quickly and matched the order exactly.
“It was delivered quick and was exactly as ordered!”
Product matched pictures, priced well, and shipped quickly.
“Exactly as pictured, good price.”
Watch arrived in perfect, like-new condition with timely shipping.
“received on time in perfect condition”
Both watches arrived quickly with original boxes and warranty cards.
“arrived quickly and with all original boxes and warranty cards.”
Purchase arrived quickly and the website was very easy to navigate.
“navigating through the website was super easy”
Item description misrepresented the band material; watch otherwise nice.
“The listing says Velcro band, BUT I got a rubber/silicon band.”
Found a two-tone Seiko at a great sale price and fast shipping.
“which also came with a great sale price!”
Item was never delivered and company blamed USPS despite complaint.
“My item was never delivered”
Item was new as advertised and seller was communicative.
“New as advertised in perfect condition. Very communicative and personal.”
Stones were tiny and did not match the ordered ruby description.
“its crap not even the right color ordered ruby”
Store had fast communication and is recommended.
“Fast communication with the store, I really recommend”
Item exceeded expectations and was a great purchase.
“Absolutely gorgeous, I am so happy to have gotten this item.”
Watch matched the description and shipped quickly to the UK.
“Watch was exactly as described. Fast shipping to UK.”
Watch exceeded expectations and attracted coworker interest.
“Watch was better than I expected.”
Found the best price by $40 and received fast shipping.
“Great pricing, this was the best deal on the luminox I wanted by $40+”
Promotions allowed purchase of a luxury watch for much less.
“Managed to snag a luxury watch for a fraction of the price.”
Tom provided knowledgeable, helpful service and went the extra mile.
“Tom was very knowledgeable, helpful and willing to go the extra mile”
This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.
My Gift Stop is an online retail seller that customers review for product authenticity, delivery reliability, pricing and post-purchase support. This summary synthesizes only the provided customer reviews so prospective buyers can quickly gauge recurring strengths and issues when researching the store.