Skip to content

HorseSaddleShop
Reviews & Experiences

Reviews describe sharply different experiences. Some customers received authentic saddles that arrived well packaged and said the consignment process was straightforward. Other buyers and sellers reported missing orders, unpaid consignments, and messages that went unanswered. Condition feedback ranges from collector-ready pieces to stained or misrepresented saddles.

View reviews Write review

Overview & Key Metrics

Review count
9
Sources
trustpilot.com
Last updated
March 2026

What reviewers often mention

🎯

Service quality

Service comes up most often, with comments split between smooth transactions and major problems. Positive reviews mention an easy consignment flow and fast international delivery. Negative accounts describe missing shipments, alleged payment failures, and complaints that never got resolved.

💰

Value for money

Value perceptions shift with condition and fulfilment. Some reviewers describe used saddles as overpriced and say new saddles stained clothing, which lowered value for them. Mentions of fair deals appear only occasionally.

⚡

User experience

Experiences range from clear paperwork and simple send-in steps to support that did not respond. Some reviewers noted quick delivery or secure packaging, while others said there was no follow-up after payment or that replies felt rude. Several accounts also point to shipping costs or payments not being received as recurring pain points.

🔧

Product quality

Condition on arrival varies widely. Some customers received pristine, collector-ready items in original packaging. Others report stained or misrepresented saddles, including ongoing problems such as oil transferring to clothing.

📞

Communication

Communication differs sharply across reviews. A small group mention clear, quick messages and paperwork. Many others report silence, ignored questions, or abrupt staff responses.

⭐

Overall experience

Reviews are polarized between dependable fulfilment and serious breakdowns. Several shoppers praised the packaging and the ease of the transaction, while many sellers and buyers reported missing payments and orders. That gap between high and low ratings shows up repeatedly.

All Reviews

For each review, the core experience based on original source reviews.

All Reviews

Sources: Trustpilot (9) · Quotes shortened · As of: March 2026

Danielle Smith quality

Received a retired Breyer horse well packaged in a pristine, collector-ready box.

“It came extremely well packaged in a pristine box”

Feb 03, 2026 · trustpilot.com
Danielle Smith
Feb 03, 2026 · trustpilot.com
Erin Kalesnikoff service

Paid via E transfer, did not receive product and alleges fraud.

“Do not order from this company.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Cynthia Bauer service

Easy consignment process with clear paperwork, shipping, and payment after sale.

“I was impressed by how easy it was to send the saddle.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Canadian Mom service

Ordered products never received and company did not respond to inquiries.

“I ordered products from Horse Saddles Shop and never received them.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Karissa Rosales quality

Received a misrepresented, stained used saddle that did not fit and was overpriced.

“dont buy used saddles from em”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Gidget Maxwell quality

New saddle arrived with oil stains and continued to stain clothing despite repairs.

“it’s still leaving oil stains on my pants.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Jo Rose service

Consigned saddle, paid expensive shipping, but never received payment and rude responses.

“Never got paid.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com
Diab service

Fast international delivery and original products.

“Fast international delivery , Original products.”

Oct 01, 2025 · trustpilot.com

Share Your Experience

Help other customers by sharing your experience with HorseSaddleShop. Your review will be collected and included in our ongoing analysis.

Click to rate

Sources and methodology

This page combines submitted experiences with public reviews from platforms such as Google, Trustpilot, etc. Recurring points are summarized without changing the content of reviews.

About HorseSaddleShop

HorseSaddleShop is an online store that sells equestrian saddles and horse tack. It offers Western and English saddles, along with accessories like girths, saddle pads, and bridles. Listings usually include photos, measurements, and material details to help with fit and selection. The site serves riders looking for new and used saddles and related leather care products.